What Schmidt & Hunter Taught Us About Selection Method Validity and What HR Still Gets Wrong

Discover what 85 years of selection research reveals about hiring. Learn which predictors actually work and why most organizations still get it wrong.
What Schmidt & Hunter Taught Us About Selection Method Validity and What HR Still Gets Wrong
"The validity of GMA measures for predicting job performance is now, after over 85 years of research, well established. There is no longer any scientific basis for denying GMA's validity. In a competitive world, organizations using suboptimal selection methods unnecessarily handicap themselves." — Frank L. Schmidt & John E. Hunter, Psychological Bulletin (1998)
Executive Summary
What if the most influential research on hiring validity was published over 25 years ago—and most organizations still haven't implemented it? In 1998, Frank L. Schmidt and John E. Hunter published a landmark meta-analysis synthesizing 85 years of personnel selection research. Their work identified which hiring methods actually predict job performance—and which don't.
Despite being one of the most cited and influential publications in Industrial/Organizational Psychology, their findings remain largely ignored by organizations. Most continue using low-validity methods while overlooking proven predictors.
This analysis explains what Schmidt & Hunter discovered, why their findings challenged conventional hiring practices, and why understanding validity coefficients is critical for building high-performing organizations.
The Problem: Why HR Hiring Practices Diverge from Science
Most organizations continue using hiring methods with minimal predictive validity. Schmidt & Hunter note that many organizations rely on unstructured interviews, resumes, and biographical information—methods with validity coefficients ranging from 0.10 to 0.38. Meanwhile, they avoid or under-utilize general mental ability (GMA) tests and structured interviews—methods with validity coefficients of 0.51 to 0.58 or higher.
This divergence between what research proves works and what organizations actually use creates enormous competitive disadvantages. As Schmidt and Hunter stated: "In a competitive world, organizations using suboptimal selection methods unnecessarily handicap themselves."
The economic stakes are massive: gains from improving selection method validity can amount to literally millions of dollars over time through increased output, reduced turnover, and improved quality. Yet this science remains largely unimplemented.
Understanding Validity: The Foundation of Selection Science
Predictive validity is the correlation between a selection method and future job performance. It's measured using validity coefficients (r) ranging from -1.0 to +1.0, where:
r = 0.35 or higher is considered "very beneficial" in practical contexts
r = 0.20-0.34 is considered "somewhat useful"
r < 0.20 is considered "unlikely to be useful"
The relationship between validity and utility is directly proportional: increasing the predictive validity coefficient increases the utility of the selection process and organizational performance. A selection method with r = 0.65 is approximately 3.8 times more effective at predicting job success than a method with r = 0.17.
The Schmidt & Hunter Meta-Analysis: What 85 Years of Research Reveals
Schmidt & Hunter's meta-analysis systematically reviewed validity research on 19 different selection methods, examining literally thousands of studies spanning nine decades. Their approach—now called the Schmidt-Hunter method of meta-analysis—corrected for statistical artifacts (sampling error, measurement error, range restriction) that had previously obscured true validity relationships.
Unlock the Full Research
Create a free account or sign in to access the complete methodology, deep-dive analysis, and key implementation frameworks.
Don't have an account? It's free to join.
Organization Learning Labs
Research & Insights Division



Comments