Organizational Learning & Leadership

Thomas-Kilmann Conflict Styles Explained: How to Choose the Right Approach at Work

Organization Learning Labs·Jan 16, 2026·10 min read
Thomas-Kilmann Conflict Styles Explained: How to Choose the Right Approach at Work

Master Thomas-Kilmann's five conflict styles: competing, collaborating, compromising, avoiding, accommodating. Learn when to use each for better outcomes.

74

Thomas-Kilmann Conflict Styles Explained: How to Choose the Right Approach at Work

What if your default way of handling conflict is actually making things worse—not because you're wrong, but because the situation calls for a different approach?

Executive Summary

Kenneth Thomas and Ralph Kilmann's conflict resolution framework identifies five distinct approaches to handling disagreement, each varying along two dimensions: assertiveness (how much you prioritize your own concerns) and cooperativeness (how much you prioritize others' concerns). These five styles—competing, collaborating, compromising, avoiding, and accommodating—are not equally effective in all situations. Research spanning decades and multiple industries reveals that the most effective leaders and teams adapt their conflict style strategically based on what the situation demands. Understanding when each style serves performance and when it sabotages it is essential for navigating workplace disagreements productively.

The Two Dimensions: Assertiveness and Cooperativeness

The Thomas-Kilmann model is built on a simple yet powerful framework consisting of two axes:

  • Assertiveness measures the extent to which you pursue your own concerns and goals in a conflict situation. High assertiveness means you clearly communicate your position and pursue your objectives. Low assertiveness means you de-emphasize your own needs and avoid pressing your point.

  • Cooperativeness measures the extent to which you seek to satisfy others' concerns and find mutually acceptable solutions. High cooperativeness means you actively work to understand others' perspectives and find solutions that work for everyone. Low cooperativeness means you focus narrowly on your position without regard for others' needs.

These two dimensions combine to create a two-by-two matrix from which five distinct conflict styles emerge. Each style is neither inherently "good" nor "bad"—rather, each is more or less effective depending on the situation, stakes, and relationship dynamics.

The Five Conflict Styles

1. Competing: High Assertiveness, Low Cooperativeness

The competing style is direct, forceful, and focused on winning. Individuals using this approach pursue their own concerns vigorously, often at others' expense. They pursue a "win-lose" outcome, asserting their position strongly without accommodating alternative perspectives.

When competing works:

  • High-stakes, time-sensitive decisions requiring immediate action

  • Defending important principles or rights

  • Situations where the other party lacks valid input or expertise

  • Emergencies requiring rapid decision-making

  • When backing down would set a poor precedent

When competing backfires:

  • Overuse damages relationships and erodes trust

  • Prevents exploration of superior alternatives

  • Creates resentment and disengagement

  • Suppresses information from lower-power individuals who have valuable input

Empirical Evidence: Research on medical residents found that those with high competing but low avoiding scores performed significantly better on administrative duties (p < .05). However, residents who relied exclusively on competing showed lower communication effectiveness and relationship quality.

2. Collaborating: High Assertiveness, High Cooperativeness

The collaborating style seeks to fully satisfy both parties' concerns through open dialogue, creative problem-solving, and integrative solutions. Collaborators invest time in understanding underlying needs, exploring alternatives, and finding "win-win" outcomes that neither party could achieve alone.

When collaborating works:

  • Complex problems requiring diverse perspectives and expertise

  • Long-term relationships where trust is essential

  • Situations where integrating different viewpoints improves decisions

  • Building shared commitment to solutions

  • Strengthening team cohesion and psychological safety

When collaborating is impractical:

  • Time-critical decisions with tight deadlines

  • Situations where exploration would compromise safety

  • When parties lack genuine willingness to engage

  • Resource constraints preventing extended dialogue

  • Highly asymmetrical power dynamics

Empirical Evidence: A study of pharmaceutical company employees found that integrating (collaborating) style had a strong positive effect on employee performance (β = .688, t = 64.148, p < 0.001). This represents one of the strongest effects found in conflict management research.

In healthcare settings, teams using collaborative approaches to shift scheduling and resource allocation demonstrated the highest retention rates and lowest burnout among nursing staff. Collaborative and compromising approaches were "most effective in preventing potential conflicts from escalating into actual conflicts."

3. Compromising: Moderate Assertiveness, Moderate Cooperativeness

The compromising style seeks a middle ground where both parties get some of what they want but neither gets everything. It involves mutual concession—each side gives up something to reach agreement.

When compromising works:

  • Time-constrained situations requiring timely resolution

  • Issues of moderate (not critical) importance

Unlock the Full Research

Create a free account or sign in to access the complete methodology, deep-dive analysis, and key implementation frameworks.

Don't have an account? It's free to join.

O

Organization Learning Labs

Research & Insights Division

Comments

Loading comments...